Energy chief defends Semirara bid waiver, open to tweaking rules

November 17, 2026
3:06PM PHT
Updated: November 17, 2026
3:06PM PHT

Insider Spotlight

  • Energy Secretary Sharon Garin defended the DOE's restrictions on legal challenges by bidders, saying similar provisions are standard in government procurement.
  • Semirara Mining and Power Corp. accused the DOE of imposing illegal conditions requiring it to surrender its power plant, pier and other assets.
  • Garin said the government could recalibrate its bidding terms if the auction fails to attract interested parties.

Energy Secretary Sharon Garin on Tuesday defended the Department of Energy's (DOE) restrictions on legal challenges by participants in the Semirara coal mine auction, saying similar provisions are already being implemented in other government bidding exercises.

Speaking during an online press briefing on November 17, Garin said the restrictions were intended to provide stability and credibility to the bidding process.

Her remarks came a day after Semirara Mining and Power Corp. (SMPC) accused the DOE of imposing confiscatory and illegal conditions designed to discourage the company from participating in the auction for the coal mine it currently operates in Antique.

The disputed provision

SMPC said the DOE was requiring the company and its affiliates to waive their legal and constitutional rights, including their right to challenge any part of the auction in court.

Garin, however, suggested that the restriction was similar to provisions in public-private partnership bidding that prevent unsuccessful participants from challenging auction results simply because they lost.

"So this is not a new provision, I do believe," Garin said.

She maintained that comparable restrictions were already being applied in other government contracts and bidding processes.

The asset controversy

SMPC also accused the DOE of demanding that it surrender its power plant and pier, alongside hundreds of trucks, heavy equipment and proprietary know-how, as a condition for participating.

The company argued that Presidential Decree 972 expressly allows it to remove its assets within one year after its coal operating contract expires on July 14, 2027.

"These illegal bid rules will not stand in court," SMPC said.

Garin did not directly address the company's objections to the expanded asset-surrender requirements during the cited remarks.

What's next

Garin said the DOE had conducted extensive consultations with stakeholders and adjusted proposed terms based on their feedback.

She expressed confidence that the auction would attract participants but acknowledged that the government might have to reconsider its approach if interest proves insufficient.

"Now, if there are not, then we will recalibrate," Garin said.

The DOE has scheduled bid submissions for December 11, with the award targeted for January 2027.

— Edited by Daxim L. Lucas

Featured News
Explore the latest news from InsiderPH
Tuesday, 17 November 2026
Insight to the one percent
© 2024 InsiderPH, All Rights Reserved.